The Game That Got Away - Platinum Trophy Edition

We all have that game where we got so close to grabbing every single trophy, but for some reason were not able to close it out. There could be so many reason for this. Maybe you got tired of the grind that simply made the game dull to play. Perhaps the online community decided to just die, rendering certain trophies impossible to obtain. Sometimes there’s just a really tough trophy that requires a skill that we just can’t complete. Or in the case of someone on the staff, they lost their Vita, losing all progress in their games.

Whatever the reasons, we’ve all got at least one game where the chase for Platinum defeated us just when it was within our grasp. With many trophies (dead online communities and glitched trophies notwithstanding), it’s possible to continue to pursue them later, so maybe this exercise in looking back at our trophy failures could inspire us to pick up the games and work towards those Platinums once again. Or not.

With that in mind, we asked everyone on the staff about the one game that they came within a few trophies of obtaining that Platinum trophy, but regret not being able to seal the deal. Some of our trophy hunting overachievers decided to regale us with multiple stories of forever lost Platinums.

What do you think about our missed opportunities? Is there a specific game that you missed out on a Platinum that just bugs you every time you think about it? Let us know which nearly complete trophy lists bother you the most in the comments below.

Essential Reading

Now Loading Platinum Trophy

Keri Honea

I'm at 92% completion with inFamous: Second Son. I'm missing a couple of random combat trophies, but I've never bothered to get them, because the big one I'm missing that I know I won't get is the Silver trophy for finishing the game on Expert Difficulty.

The game that aggravates me the most about not having the Platinum is The LEGO Ninjago Movie Videogame. A glitch is all that is keeping me from getting the last couple of trophies. I've heard the game has been patched, which might fix my issue, but the game was not fun enough to bother going back to, even for a Platinum.
John Abrena

These 3 still bug me to this very day:

1. (Vanilla) God Eater 2 for the Vita - "Unleashed from Abyss" Hunt Magatsu Kyuubi

Reason: I lost my first Vita, together with this game.

2. Freedom Wars for the Vita - "Volunteer of the Year" Successfully complete every discretionary operation, and "Dionaea Slayer" Defeat a Dionaea-class Abductor while playing offline without falling once in battle.

Reason: Someone borrowed this game from me, then I lost my first Vita.

3. Persona 4 Golden - "Thorough Bookkeeper" Complete the Persona Compendium, "Legend of Inaba" Max out all social links, "Big Bro is Worried" Visit Nanako in the Hospital a total of 3 times

Reason: I actually needed just 1 more,Thorough Bookkeeper. I just didn't sync the data before, well, I lost my first Vita.

I am sad.
Louis Edwards

Resistance 2 will always be sitting at 90% for me. I had a hard enough time killing people online, so reaching 10,000 kills was just too many for me. It's the only trophy I needed for Platinum and since the servers are shut down, it is now unattainable.
Cameron Teague

For me, it is Sims 3 on PS3. I own 48 of 51 trophies and just never got around to grinding the other two. Missing out on growing a prefect plant and completing 1000 wishes. I would go back to complete, but would need to buy a PS3 and the game.
Anthony Nash

Mine is Submerged (a really underrated game, by the way). I’m only missing two trophies, but just never got around to exploring enough to find all the secrets and boat boosts in the game.
Zarmena Khan

I'm one of those people who struggles to replay games they've already beaten just to fulfil a trophy condition, especially if it requires doing a speedrun or something. As a result, I am only a couple trophies short of Platinum in Dishonored: Death of the Outsider and Uncharted: The Lost Legacy.

Then, there's Titanfall 2. I already beat the game on regular but must beat it on Master difficulty (which is above Hard) for a trophy. I probably would have attempted it if it wasn't held back by this rare time-challenge trophy that has taken even professional guide writers many, many attempts to unlock. Ain't nobody got time for that.
Chandler Wood

With so many trophies in my collection, there are a number of "almost Platinums" that haunt me. For Broken Age, I just need to speedrun it in under an hour. For Rogue Legacy, I just need to beat it in less than five lives. The two that bother me the most, however, are Vanquish and Grand Theft Auto IV. In Vanquish, I just need to complete the tactical challenges, and in Grand Theft Auto IV, I was turned off by the exceptionally long grind to max rank in multiplayer. I did everything else, but those last trophies tripped me up on my journey to Platinum.
Cody Gravelle

Oh, I have one that happened recently that made me super sad.

I bought FFIX for PS4, and made it a goal to Platinum it as a treat to myself. I made it all the way through the game before realizing I had missed one of Stiltzkin's items at some point during the playthrough, which meant I couldn't complete the trophy related to him. After so many hours already being spent on a game I'd already played many times, and a growing backlog of more current titles, I've had to make peace with the fact I'm never getting that Platinum after all.