Note: This opinion piece reflects the views of the author and not PlayStation LifeStyle as a whole.
I love JRPGs (Japanese Role-Playing Games). I sunk hundreds of hours into Pokémon and Final Fantasy series as a kid, and I loved everything about the genre. I got to experience interesting new worlds filled with interesting characters. I built a party of warriors and watched as their skills in combat improved over time as they also grew as individuals outside of fighting. Deep storylines, top notch graphics and gameplay that was ever evolving. How could I not love the genre?
Sadly, as a fan of the genre I have to recognize that it hasn’t exactly been firing on all cylinders as of late. While RPGs like The Witcher and Divinity have shown me that these interesting worlds still exist, it’s been quite some time since a Japanese one has. I love JRPGs, but the genre as a whole has grown stagnant and in some cases games are regressing. It’s time for change.
Identifying The Problem
Before the genre can change for the better, some core issues need to be identified. One of the biggest issues that plague JRPGs is that they are basically the only modern games that rely on save points anymore. That needs to go. Save points aren’t included because they enhance the gameplay experience, they’re only there because that’s the way it has always been. That is terrible reasoning and it encapsulates the problem with so many JRPGs: they are living in the past.
Save points only prove to frustrate in 2016. In countless JRPGs I’ve spent hours levelling up my characters, only to die and find out that my party is back where they started. That doesn’t add any extra challenge, it only adds frustration. The genre needs to embrace auto-saving like every single other game and save points need to die.
Another major issue is grinding. JRPGs love to boast how they are 50-60 hours long, but how many hours are actually meaningful? I often find myself forced to kill meaningless random enemies for hours on end in order to improve my characters just so I can continue to advance the story. That sucks. There isn’t anything fun about grinding, and JRPGs need to become shorter more curated experiences. Most role playing games are already lengthy without all of this needless fluff and there’s really no reason to extend it further.
Let’s Get Technical
JRPGs used to be some of the most gorgeous games available. I remember marvelling at the cutscenes in Final Fantasy VIII, and being blown away by how good JRPGs looked in general. I wasn’t simply playing a game, I was being transported to a marvelous world filled with magic. Nowadays, most JRPGs look like they are a generation behind graphically.
One of my complaints with the Hyperdimension Neptunia series was how the games always looked like a bad PS2 game that was up-resed. I’m seeing this become the norm within the genre instead of an aberration. Look at recent high profile JRPG releases like Star Ocean V and Nights of Azure. Both games are graphically underwhelming and are largely given a pass by the genre’s fan-base. That is ridiculous and with that attitude Japanese role playing games will never improve since they don’t have to.
There’s also a lot of jank technically in a lot of modern RPGs. When I played Xenoblade Chronicles X last year, I constantly went from being impressed to wondering how such a gorgeous game could look so bad. I would come across textures that looked like they were made for an original PlayStation game, and for some reason my character could walk right through cars as if they didn’t exist. This only serves to break the illusion, and it takes me out of the world that the developer is trying to soak me in. These hiccups (like Star Ocean‘s terrible camera) wouldn’t be accepted anywhere else, yet once again I see fans arguing that there isn’t a problem. As someone who cares, that’s a bummer.
The reason why I loved JRPGs was that they often told the best stories in gaming. That is rarely the case anymore, as more and more fall upon generic tropes and I often feel like I’ve already played the game before I finished them. Why do half of the protagonists in JRPGs suffer from amnesia? Is it that difficult to come up with a different framing device for a narrative? Why do so many role playing game characters have zero depth to them and feel like a stereotype anymore?
Modern JRPGs need to go back to telling meaningful stories again. Stories that are original. Ones where I’m on the edge of my seat needing to know what happens next. Storytelling is the heart and soul of RPGs, so I can only hope that developers will focus more on them in the future. Crazy twists aren’t even needed, just logical stories that have me rooting for the good guys as they accomplish something meaningful.
Past, Present and Future
No other genre has its past celebrated over its present as much as JRPGs. Ask somebody what they think the best JRPG is and they’ll often answer Chrono Trigger or Final Fantasy VI. If you’re lucky, you might even hear someone mention a game from the PS2 era such as Persona 4. What won’t be mentioned is a PlayStation 3 or 4 game. While the genre has flourished on handhelds in the past decade, it’s fading into obscurity on consoles.
First-person shooter fans won’t argue that the original Half-Life is the epitome of the genre, nor do they romanticize when they couldn’t look up or down in Doom. That’s because the FPS has evolved. I sincerely hope that we’ll get to a time when Chrono Trigger is no longer held up as the best that JRPGs have to offer, and when Persona 4 is simply just a good example in the genre instead of one of the best.
High profile releases such as Final Fantasy XV and Persona 5 will have an opportunity to give the genre a spotlight again. Hopefully they’ll be able to live up to the hype and wow gamers. It’ll mean nothing if they aren’t followed up meaningfully, though. The genre as a whole needs to improve, so hopefully developers will spend time modernizing and making sure that modern JRPGs become must play video games again. It can be done.
It's Time for Modern JRPGs to Evolve